Extracted Text
iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS—Continued
Page
A. The Third, Fourth, Eighth and Ninth
Circuits have faithfully applied
Santobello’s instruction that promises
in plea agreements must be binding
on the government, applying basic
principles of contract law to find that
obligations entered into on behalf of
the “United States” or the
“Government” apply to the federal
government throughout the nation .... 9
B. The Second and the Seventh Circuits
apply the opposite presumption. They
refuse to enforce a promise made on
behalf of the “United States” or “the
Government” except against the
particular United States Attorney’s
office which entered into the
agreement, unless the agreement
expressly reiterates that the term
“United States” does in fact mean the
entire country as a whole................066 11
II. The Second Circuit’s decision below is
wrong and violates the principles set
forth in this Court’s prior opinions .......... 12
A. Both Annabi and the opinion below
were wrongly decided under
Santobello and Giglio ...........cccccccceeeeeee 13
B. Ordinary principles of contract
interpretation compel Annabi and
Maxwell to be reversed.............:::0000008 14
DOJ-OGR-00000038